Selection of Soft-Seated vs. Metal-Seated Butterfly Valves
Soft-Seated (Soft Seal)
If one side of the sealing pair is a metal material and the other side is an elastic non-metallic material, it is called a “soft seal.” This type of seal provides relatively good sealing performance, but it is not resistant to high temperatures, is prone to wear, and has relatively poor mechanical properties. Examples: steel + rubber; steel + PTFE; etc.
The soft sealing seat is made of a non-metallic material with certain strength, hardness and temperature resistance. It provides good sealing performance and can achieve zero leakage, but its service life and temperature adaptability are relatively poor.
Hard-Seated (Hard Seal)
If both sides of the sealing pair are metal materials or other relatively hard materials, it is called a "hard seal." This type of seal has relatively poorer sealing performance, but offers high-temperature resistance, wear resistance and good mechanical properties. Examples: steel + steel; steel + copper; steel + graphite; steel + alloy steel. (Here "steel" may also be cast iron or cast steel, and "alloy steel" may also be overlay-welded or spray-coated alloy.)
Hard seals are made of metal and have relatively poorer sealing performance, although some manufacturers claim that zero leakage can be achieved.
Soft seals cannot meet process requirements for some corrosive media, while hard seals can solve this problem. The two seal types are complementary. In terms of sealing performance, soft seals are relatively better, but hard seals can now also meet the corresponding requirements.
- Advantages of soft-seated valves:
good sealing performance.
- Disadvantages of soft-seated valves:
easy aging, wear, and short service life.
long service life, but sealing performance is relatively poorer than that of soft-seated valves.
Structural Differences and Other Considerations
The main structural differences are as follows:
Aspect | Soft-Seated Butterfly Valve | Hard-Seated Butterfly Valve |
Structure | Mostly centerline type | Mostly single-offset, double-offset or triple-offset type |
Temperature resistance | Used in ambient-temperature environments | Can be used in low-temperature, ambient-temperature and high-temperature environments |
Pressure | Low pressure to atmospheric pressure | Can also be used in medium- and high-pressure operating conditions |
Sealing performance | Soft-seated and triple-offset hard-seated butterfly valves have relatively good sealing performance | Triple-offset butterfly valves can maintain good sealing under high-pressure and high-temperature conditions |
What High Temperature Can a PTFE-Lined Butterfly Valve Withstand?
The lining material of a PTFE-lined butterfly valve is a fluoroplastic. On the market, polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) is the most common lining material.
PTFE has excellent corrosion resistance and can be used with highly corrosive media such as strong acids and strong alkalis. It also has certain heat and cold resistance, with a service temperature range of -196 to 200°C.
However, the temperature resistance range of PTFE does not mean that a PTFE-lined butterfly valve can achieve the same range. A valve is a wear/consumable item. When installed and used in a pipeline, a PTFE-lined butterfly valve is subject to continuous corrosion and erosion by the medium.
The above temperature range of PTFE material is obtained under ideal conditions. In reality, considering factors such as manufacturing process, production environment and technical level, the temperature resistance of PTFE-lined butterfly valves cannot reach the ideal requirement. Based on statistical observation and analysis, regarding the question of how much temperature a PTFE-lined butterfly valve can withstand, products from manufacturers with good material performance can withstand up to 200°C, while general market products can only withstand up to 150°C.
Advantages of PTFE-Lined Butterfly Valves
Relying on the excellent properties of PTFE, PTFE-lined butterfly valves can effectively isolate the medium from the valve body, thereby achieving corrosion protection. They are widely used in petroleum, chemical, environmental protection and other fields.
At normal temperature and pressure, PTFE-lined butterfly valves have higher cost-effectiveness and can be used to replace butterfly valves with stainless steel bodies.
PTFE-lined butterfly valves are often used in operating conditions with corrosive media. Therefore, when purchasing PTFE-lined butterfly valves, be sure to ensure the quality and safety of the valves.